Free Through Insurance

Spectra S1 vs S2: Is the Battery Worth the Upgrade?

The Spectra S1 and Spectra S2 share the same hospital-strength motor, the same closed-system design, and the same quiet operation. The only real difference between them is that the S1 has a built-in rechargeable battery while the S2 requires a wall outlet. That single feature changes how and where you can pump, and for many moms, it is the deciding factor. Here is a full spectra s1 vs s2 breakdown to help you choose.
$0 out of pocket
Free shipping
We handle all paperwork

Get Started

Please enter a valid email address.
Please select state
No states found
Please select a state.
Please select state first
No insurance providers found
Please select your insurance provider.

Accepted by 300+ Insurance Plans

AetnaBlue CrossCignaHumanaUnitedHealthcareTricare

$0 Out of Pocket

Most insurance plans fully cover your breast pump under the ACA.

Free Shipping

Your pump ships directly to your door at no extra charge.

We Handle Paperwork

We verify your benefits and file everything with your insurer.

Ships in 3–5 Days

Most orders arrive within a week of insurance verification.

Quick Verdict: Spectra S1 vs S2

These are functionally identical pumps. Same suction power, same closed-system backflow protector, same adjustable vacuum and cycle controls, same nightlight, same let-down mode. The only difference is portability. The S1 Plus includes a rechargeable lithium-ion battery that delivers approximately 3 hours of cordless pumping per charge. The S2 Plus must be plugged into an outlet at all times. If you pump exclusively at home and have easy access to outlets, the S2 saves you about $40 and gives you the exact same performance. If you commute, pump at work, or want the freedom to move around your house without being tethered to a cord, the S1 is worth every extra dollar.

Spectra S1 Plus: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Built-in rechargeable battery — Approximately 3 hours of pumping per full charge. Pump in the car, at work, in the nursery, or anywhere without searching for an outlet. This is the S1’s defining advantage.
  • Same hospital-strength motor as the S2 — You are not trading suction power for portability. The S1 delivers identical vacuum strength and cycle speed whether running on battery or plugged in.
  • Closed-system hygiene — The backflow protector keeps milk completely out of the tubing and motor housing. No mold risk, no bacteria buildup in hard-to-clean areas.
  • Workplace-ready — The combination of quiet operation and cordless function makes the S1 ideal for pumping in an office, break room, or lactation room without needing to sit next to a wall socket.

Cons:

  • Costs approximately $40 more than the S2 — At retail, the S1 typically runs around $200 compared to the S2 at $160. Through insurance, the upgrade fee varies by plan.
  • Slightly heavier — The battery adds a small amount of weight. The difference is marginal but noticeable if you are carrying it back and forth daily.
  • Battery degrades over time — Like any rechargeable battery, capacity diminishes with repeated charge cycles. After 12 to 18 months of heavy use, you may notice shorter run times.

Takes less than 60 seconds. Most moms pay $0.

Spectra S2 Plus: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Lower cost — At roughly $160 retail, the S2 is one of the best values in breast pumps. Through insurance, it is one of the most commonly covered pumps at zero out-of-pocket cost across virtually every insurer.
  • Identical suction and performance — The S2 uses the same motor, the same vacuum range, and the same dual-phase expression technology as the S1. There is no compromise in pumping output.
  • Never runs out of battery — Plugged-in pumps deliver consistent, full-power suction every session. There is no battery to charge, no degradation over time, and no risk of running out mid-session.
  • Closed-system design — Same backflow protector as the S1. Same hygiene advantages. Same easy-clean tubing.

Cons:

  • Must be near an outlet — Every pumping session requires a wall socket. This limits where you can comfortably pump and can be inconvenient during nighttime sessions or travel.
  • Less practical for working moms — If your workplace lactation room does not have a conveniently placed outlet, or if you pump in different locations throughout the day, the cord becomes a real limitation.
  • No portability — You cannot pump in the car, at a park, or anywhere else without power. For moms who value flexibility, this is a meaningful drawback.

Who Should Pick the S1 vs the S2?

Pick the S1 if: You work outside the home and need to pump during the day. You want to pump in different rooms without an extension cord. You travel, even occasionally. You pump in the car during commutes. You value the flexibility to move freely during sessions.

Pick the S2 if: You pump primarily at home. You have a dedicated pumping station near an outlet. You are on a tight budget and want the lowest possible cost. You are an exclusive pumper who values consistent wall-power suction over portability. You plan to use it as a stationary, reliable workhorse.

The bottom line: If your insurance covers both at the same price or the upgrade fee is small, choose the S1. The battery is one of those features you may not think you need until you are stuck in a room without a free outlet at 2 a.m. If there is a meaningful cost difference and you genuinely only pump at home, the S2 delivers identical results for less money.

Takes less than 60 seconds. Most moms pay $0.

Insurance Coverage: Spectra S1 vs S2

The Spectra S2 Plus is one of the most widely covered breast pumps in the United States. It appears in the standard, zero-cost tier of nearly every insurance plan that covers breast pumps under the ACA. The Spectra S1 Plus is also covered by most plans, but it often falls into an upgrade tier that may require a small out-of-pocket fee, typically between $20 and $50 depending on your insurer.

Some plans cover both at no cost. Others offer the S2 free and the S1 at a reduced upgrade price. The only way to know your exact coverage is to check your specific plan details.

Pumps for Mom makes this simple. Enter your insurance information and we will show you whether your plan covers the S1, the S2, or both — and exactly what you will pay. We handle all the paperwork and ship your pump directly to your door.

Spectra S1 & S2 Pumps Through Insurance

Spectra S2 Plus

Spectra S2 Plus

Covered by most insurance plans

Medela Pump in Style

Medela Pump in Style

Covered by most insurance plans

Lansinoh Smartpump 3.0

Lansinoh Smartpump 3.0

Covered by most insurance plans

Most insurance plans cover a breast pump at no cost to you.

What Moms Are Saying

Rated 4.9/5 by thousands of moms

★★★★★

“I had no idea my insurance would cover a Spectra pump at no cost. Pumps for Mom handled everything—I just picked my pump and it arrived in 4 days.”

Jessica M.

Dallas, TX

★★★★★

“The process was so simple. I entered my insurance info, picked the Medela Freestyle, and they took care of all the paperwork. Truly zero hassle.”

Sarah K.

Richmond, VA

★★★★★

“As a first-time mom I was overwhelmed by the options. Their team helped me choose the right pump for my needs and I paid nothing out of pocket.”

Amanda R.

Phoenix, AZ

Spectra S1 vs S2 FAQ

Is there any difference between the Spectra S1 and S2 besides the battery?

No. The S1 and S2 use the same motor, the same suction range, the same closed-system backflow protector, the same let-down mode, and the same nightlight. The only hardware difference is the S1’s built-in rechargeable battery. Performance, output, and hygiene are identical.

How long does the Spectra S1 battery last?

A fully charged Spectra S1 battery lasts approximately 3 hours of pumping, which typically covers 4 to 6 pumping sessions depending on your session length and suction settings. Charging takes about 2 to 3 hours via the included power adapter.

Can I use the Spectra S2 with a portable battery pack?

Some moms use aftermarket battery packs designed for the S2, but these are third-party products not made by Spectra. They add bulk and may not deliver consistent power. If portability matters to you, the S1 with its built-in battery is the more reliable solution.

Does insurance cover the Spectra S1 or only the S2?

Most insurance plans cover both the S1 and S2. The S2 is almost always available at zero cost. The S1 is frequently available as an upgrade, sometimes free and sometimes with a small upgrade fee depending on your plan. Enter your insurance details at Pumps for Mom to see your exact coverage.

Check Your Spectra Coverage

Find out if your insurance covers the Spectra S1, S2, or both at no cost to you.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please select state
No states found
Please select a state.
Please select state first
No insurance providers found
Please select your insurance provider.